SCHEDULE 14A
(RULE 14a-101)
INFORMATION REQUIRED IN PROXY STATEMENT
SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION
PROXY STATEMENT PURSUANT TO SECTION 14(a) OF THE
SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
Filed by the Registrant [ ]
Filed by a Party other than the Registrant [X]
Check the appropriate box:
[ ] | Preliminary Proxy Statement | |
[ ] | Definitive Proxy Statement | |
[ ] | Confidential, for Use of the Commission Only (as permitted by Rule 14a-6(e)(2)) | |
[X] | Definitive Additional Materials | |
[ ] | Soliciting Material Pursuant to Rule 14a-12 |
HEWLETT-PACKARD COMPANY
WALTER B. HEWLETT, EDWIN E. VAN BRONKHORST AND THE WILLIAM R. HEWLETT REVOCABLE TRUST
Payment of Filing Fee (Check the appropriate box):
[X] | Fee not required. | ||||
[ ] | Fee computed on table below per Exchange Act Rules 14a-6(i)(4) and 0-11. | ||||
(1) | Title of each class of securities to which transaction applies: |
||||
(2) | Aggregate number of securities to which transaction applies: |
||||
(3) | Per unit price or other underlying value of transaction
computed pursuant to Exchange Act Rule 0-11 (Set forth the
amount on which the filing fee is calculated and state how it
was determined): |
||||
(4) | Proposed maximum aggregate value of transaction: |
||||
(5) | Total fee paid: |
||||
[ ] | Fee
paid previously with preliminary materials: |
||||
[ ] | Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid previously. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or the form or schedule and the date of its filing. | ||||
(1) | Amount Previously Paid: |
||||
(2) | Form, Schedule or Registration Statement No.: |
||||
(3) | Filing Party: |
||||
(4) | Date Filed: |
Enclosed with this Schedule 14A is a revised Report Relating to Executive Compensation (the Report), together with various documents referred to in the Report. The only change to the Report filed by the Filing Persons on February 26, 2002 is the description on page six of the annual base salary and target annual bonus contemplated for Mr. Capellas.
The Filing Persons are filing the additional documents in response to misleading statements made by or on behalf of HP with respect to the Report, including statements made by HP to the effect that Mr. Hewlett is fabricating information solely in an effort to gain votes and statements made by HPs outside legal counsel to the effect that Mr. Capellas and Ms. Fiorina merely floated some general terms for future pay packages and that [t]hose early discussions did not include the specific figures Hewlett cited.1
The additional documents include:
| A side letter agreement from HPs outside legal counsel to Compaqs outside legal counsel that contains term sheets embodying the contemplated terms of the employment agreements for Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas; | ||
| Term sheets that contain very detailed information relating to the contemplated employment agreements for Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas; | ||
| Term sheets indicating that the total estimated current value of the stock options was $57 million for Ms. Fiorina and $38 million for Mr. Capellas; | ||
| Minutes of the September 3, 2001 meeting of the compensation committee of HPs board of directors which reflect the decision made by the compensation committee in favor of the employment contract for Mr. Capellas as presented to the compensation committee; and | ||
| Minutes of the September 20, 2001 meeting of the compensation committee which reflect that the compensation committee approved new employment terms for Ms. Fiorina.2 |
REPORT RELATING TO EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION
I. | INTRODUCTION |
Walter B. Hewlett is a member of the compensation committee of the board of directors of Hewlett-Packard Company. He participated in each of the numerous compensation committee meetings and extensive discussions relating to the compensation packages contemplated for Carly Fiorina, HPs Chairman and CEO, and Michael Capellas, Compaqs Chairman and CEO, in connection with the proposed HP/Compaq merger.
Mr. Hewlett has repeatedly attempted to persuade HP to disclose the compensation packages contemplated for Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas. Despite these attempts:
| HP has repeatedly refused to disclose such packages; | ||
| HP has attempted to create a record to support its refusal to disclose such packages until after stockholders vote on the proposed merger; and | ||
| HP, through its outside legal counsel, has attempted to pressure Mr. Hewlett into keeping this information secret. |
Mr. Hewlett strongly believes that the details of the compensation packages contemplated for Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas are important to an investors consideration of the proposed HP/Compaq merger, and that HPs stockholders deserve to know this information. The need for additional disclosure is particularly compelling in light of the fact that:
| Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas are leading a massive promotional campaign, which includes in-person meetings with investors, in support of the proposed HP/Compaq merger; | ||
| HP has failed to disclose important aspects of the written record, including an undisclosed side letter agreement (entered into on the date of the merger agreement) between its outside legal counsel and Compaqs outside legal counsel; | ||
| HP has repeatedly changed the compensation-related disclosures contained in its own proxy statement; | ||
| the agreement by Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas to decline retention bonuses has been widely publicized; and | ||
| under the terms of the compensation packages that were being contemplated, Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas would have received compensation packages valued at more than $115 million.1 |
II. | HPS ATTEMPT TO HIDE THE BALL WITH RESPECT TO COMPENSATION PACKAGES |
A. | HP Has Failed to Disclose Important Aspects of the Written Record |
The disclosure in HPs proxy statement with respect to executive compensation does not tell the whole story. It fails to describe the written record which reflects detailed terms of compensation packages contemplated for Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas.
| Merger Agreement. Section 5.12(c) of the Merger Agreement provides that: HP will negotiate in good faith with certain persons who are current senior executives of HP and Compaq who are expected to become (or continue to be) senior executives of HP following the Merger for such persons to accept the positions and the terms of employment previously discussed between Compaq and HP. (emphasis added) | ||
| Side Letter. The terms of employment previously discussed to which the Merger Agreement refers are contained in term sheets attached to a so-called side letter from Mr. Sonsini to outside counsel for Compaq. The side letter provided that For our mutual reference, I am attaching hereto term sheets embodying terms of the agreements previously discussed and to be negotiated in good faith between HP and the individuals listed on Exhibit A hereto, in accordance with Section 5.12(c) of the Merger Agreement. | ||
| Detailed Term Sheets. The attachments to the side letter include a seven-page term sheet dated September 4, 2001 with very detailed information relating to the proposed employment agreement for Ms. Fiorina, and a nine-page term sheet with very detailed information relating to the proposed employment agreement for Mr. Capellas. The term sheets include information relating to title, duties, term of employment, base salary, benefits, target bonus, equity compensation, including number of stock options, death or disability, change of control vesting and severance. The structure of the employee stock options, including exercise price and vesting schedule, were, according to handwritten notations on the term sheets, to be determined within the next seven days. | ||
| Compensation Committee Approval. On September 3, 2001, the compensation committee of HPs board of directors stated support for Michael Capellas contract as presented to the meeting. On September 20, 2001, the compensation committee of HPs board of directors discussed and approved new employment agreement terms for Carly Fiorina. |
2.
| Subsequent Notation on Minutes. Subsequent to the September 20, 2001 compensation committee meeting, the minutes of the meeting were prepared. The minutes contain an asterisk next to the discussion of the employment agreements for the top twelve executive officers, together with the following notation: Subsequent to the adjournment of the meeting, members of the Committee determined that the Committee had not agreed on the exercise price for the options, specifically whether the performance-based blocks would be priced at FMV or premium prices. The minutes also state the Committee approved new employment agreement terms, effective on the merger for Ms. Fiorina. Following the statement of approval, another asterisk appears, together with the following notation: [a]s noted previously, it was subsequently determined that the Committee had not reached agreement on the pricing terms of the option component of the package. Accordingly, all components of the package, which are interrelated, will be reconsidered at a future meeting. Mr. Hewlett did not participate in any subsequent determination by the Committee and first became aware of the alleged determination that the previously approved employment arrangements were no longer approved after the compensation committee minutes were made available to the members of the compensation committee. |
B. | HP Has Repeatedly Changed the Compensation-Related Disclosures Contained in Its Own Proxy Statement |
| HPs First Position Relating to Executive Compensation. On November 15, 2001, HP first filed its proxy statement with the SEC. This version disclosed that HP is negotiating new employment agreements with, among others, Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas.2 | ||
| HPs Second Position Relating to Executive Compensation. On January 11, 2002, HP filed Amendment No. 2 to its proxy statement. In that amendment, HP changed for the first time, but not the last its disclosure regarding Ms. Fiorinas post-merger compensation. While the initial disclosure said HP was in fact negotiating with Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas, the January 11 proxy statement said: HP plans to negotiate promptly following the completion of the merger new employment agreements with Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas.3 | ||
| HPs January 24, 2002 SEC Filing Relating to Executive Compensation. On January 24, 2002, HP filed a letter with the Securities and Exchange Commission in which it disclosed that HPs full compensation committee had reported to the HP board that, while preliminary discussions had occurred regarding the executives post-transaction employment agreements, no terms have been finalized and substantial work needs to be done with respect to |
3.
performance-based compensation.4 The letter did not reveal that Mr. Hewlett, a member of the compensation committee, in fact had voiced his strong belief that the parameters of the compensation packages that were being contemplated for Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas were known to the compensation committee, and should immediately be disclosed to HPs stockholders because such information is important information that stockholders must have before voting on the proposed merger. | |||
| HPs Third Position Relating to Executive Compensation. On January 31, 2002, in Amendment No. 3 to its proxy statement, HP changed the compensation disclosure yet again. This time, in addition to saying HP would not negotiate employment agreements with the HP and Compaq executives until after the closing of the proposed merger, the proxy statement disclosed that: (i) following execution of the merger agreement, HP and Compaq determined that it would be more appropriate for the compensation committee of the newly constituted board following completion of the merger to analyze, review and determine the appropriate structure and size of compensation packages for executives of the combined company and (ii) HP had determined that the employment terms previously discussed would not serve as a benchmark for any future terms.5 Significantly, however, the Merger Agreement still makes the previously discussed terms a benchmark in future negotiations because Section 5.12(c) of the Merger Agreement still obligates HP to negotiate in good faith for Ms. Fiorina and the other executives to accept . . . the terms of employment previously discussed between Compaq and HP. |
C. | The Agreement by Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas to Decline Retention Bonuses Has Been Widely Publicized |
As demonstrated below, HP has touted, and the press has widely reported, the fact that Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas voluntarily declined millions of dollars in retention bonuses that would be paid if the proposed merger were completed. At the time the press first reported such fact, HPs proxy statement stated that HP was then negotiating new employment agreements with Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Capellas. To explain the executives decision to decline the retention bonuses [b]oth companies said the CEOs wanted to avoid the appearance of conflicts of interest as they urge on the deals completion.6 HP, however, has failed to disclose, among other things, that the total value of Ms. Fiorinas contemplated compensation package was far in excess of the value of the retention bonus that she purportedly declined to accept.
4.
| In all versions of the proxy statement HP has filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, HP has stressed that Ms. Fiorina declined to accept the right to participate in [the retention bonus] program under which she would have been entitled to receive . . . a total of $8.0 million and that Mr. Capellas similarly declined to accept more than $14 million in retention bonuses;7 | ||
| The Associated Press reported that the disclosure of [Fiorinas and Capellass] decision comes at a time when both companies are fighting to hold together the $23.7 billion deal amid opposition . . .8; | ||
| USA Today noted: Fiorina and Compaq CEO Michael Capellas turned down $8 million and $14.4 million in bonuses, respectively, to avoid conflict9; | ||
| Dow Jones ran the headline: H-P, Compaq CEOs To Forgo Retention Bonus If Deal Is Done10; | ||
| The San Jose Mercury News reported: Fiorina was offered $8 million but declined . . . Compaq . . . offered Michael Capellas $14.4 million but he also declined. The companies didnt disclose when or why the CEOs declined the payments11; | ||
| The New York Times reported: in an apparent gesture of faith in the merger, Carleton S. Fiorina, the chief executive of Hewlett-Packard, and Michael D. Capellas, the chief executive of Compaq, chose not to participate in the executive retention program12; | ||
| In January 2002, HP filed an updated proxy statement which reiterated the CEOs decision to forgo the retention bonuses; predictably, reports of the forgone bonuses proliferated yet again13; and |
5.
| On January 29, 2002, HP again referred to Ms. Fiorinas decision in its Form 10-K filed with the SEC14; additional reports in the press soon followed, including this observation from Bloomberg: Fiorina and Capellas have, graciously it seems, exempted themselves from the goodies.15 |
III. | CARLY FIORINA AND MICHAEL CAPELLAS MAY RECEIVE COMPENSATION PACKAGES VALUED AT MORE THAN $115 MILLION |
The compensation packages that were being contemplated for Carly Fiorina and Michael Capellas include:
| Carly Fiorina two-year employment contract |
| Annual base salary of $1.6 million | ||
| Target annual bonus of $4.8 million16 | ||
| 6,000,000 stock options with a total estimated current value of $57 million17 |
| Michael Capellas two-year employment contract |
| Annual base salary of $1.6 million | ||
| Target annual bonus of $3.2 million18 | ||
| 4,000,000 stock options with a total estimated current value of $38 million19 |
6.
IV. | CONCLUSION |
Mr. Hewlett believes that stockholders clearly deserve to know that the people who are actively promoting and recommending the proposed merger have interests in the merger that differ from interests of stockholders generally. He also believes that stockholders deserve to know the extent of those differences.
* * * * *
ADDITIONAL IMPORTANT INFORMATION
7.
Very truly yours, |
/s/ LARRY W. SONSINI |
Larry W. Sonsini |
Exhibit A
CSF EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT
Summary of Key Terms
Dated: September 4, 2001
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
Title: | Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer | Chairman and Chief Executive Officer |
Board of Directors: |
Member of the Board of Directors of the
Company during the term of employment. |
Continue to serve as Chairman of
the Board |
Duties: |
All the duties and responsibilities
commensurate with Executives role and with
chief executive officers of similarly-situated
companies. Serve as chief external
representative of the Company. Board shall
consider Executives recommendations with any nominations to the Board. |
Same as existing, and specifically
include: Lead corporation Decide new top level structure Establish integration charters Oversee integration effort Lead BU performance management Manage board constituents External spokesperson on direction |
Term of Employment: | At will; employment may be terminated by Executive or the Company, at any time, with notice. | 24 month term at will thereafter Agreement continues in effect throughout employment with the Company |
Base Salary: | $1,000,000 per year | $1,600,000 per year |
Benefits: | All Company standard benefits for executive officers, reimbursement of business expenses, | Same (including,
among other things, personal security, use of Company plane, |
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
immediate participation in savings and stock purchase plans, retirement plans, etc. No less than 25 days of paid time off per year. Perquisites including relocation expenses, financial counseling ($30k), Company car and driver, Company- provided personal security, and customary use of Company plane. |
car and financial
planning as currently provided to MDC) |
|
Joining Bonus: | $3,000,000. | N/A |
Annual Bonus: | Current target no less than $3,000,000, with an opportunity to earn up to a maximum bonus opportunity of $9,000,000. | Target annual incentive of
$4,800,000 (3 x base salary) |
Equity Compensation: |
Current holdings include 3.8 million option shares and 1.4 million shares of restricted stock Eligible for ongoing awards at levels commensurate with position Current equity holdings currently valued at $23.3 million |
6 million share option grant1 Eligible for ongoing awards at levels commensurate with position. |
Death or Disability: |
Disability Executive is unable to perform her material duties hereunder for six consecutive months because of physical or mental incapacity Executive gets (i) 100% vesting in all stock options, Restricted Stock and Restricted Units, (ii) |
Executive gets
(i) 100% vesting in all equity compensation awards, (ii) payment of all accrued salary, bonuses, expenses, etc., (iii) pro-rata bonus under Companys variable pay plan and (iv) lump sum equal to 1.5 x base salary and target bonus. |
- 2 -
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
payment of all accrued salary, bonuses, expenses, etc. and (iii) pro-rata bonus under Companys variable pay plan. | ||
Change of Control Vesting Acceleration |
On the date of a change of control (a) 100% vesting of any Restricted Stock (defined term) or Restricted Stock Unit (defined term), and (b) 50% vesting of each tranche of any other equity award, including any options. |
On the date of a change of control
(a) 100% vesting of any restricted stock or restricted stock unit, and (b) 50% vesting of each tranche of each option and of each tranche or each other equity award. |
Involuntary Termination
without Cause or Voluntary Termination for Good Reason: |
Executive can terminate for Good Reason within 180 days of Good Reason event. |
Same |
Payments and Benefits upon Involuntary Termination without Cause or Voluntary Termination for Good Reason: |
If Executive signs and does not revoke
release, Executive gets: Accrued salary, bonuses, expenses, etc.
Pro-rata bonus under Companys variable pay
plan
2 x base salary and target bonus (paid out
over 24 months) subject to non-compete
clawback. Severance paid out in lump-sum if
change of control after termination. If
termination occurs
in contemplation of, or within 2 years after a change of control, Executive gets 3 x base salary and highest bonus earned with respect to 2 fiscal years prior to termination, whether or not paid
2 years of continued participation in
Companys welfare plans (3 years if termination occurs within 2 years after a change of control)
3 years of service and compensation credit
|
Same, plus 3 years post-termination
to exercise all options |
- 3 -
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
under Companys defined benefit type
retirement plans if termination occurs within 2 years after a change of control
100% vesting in Restricted Stock and
Restricted Units
50% vesting of each tranche of each stock
1 year of customary outplacement servicesoption and of each tranche of each other equity award (100% vesting if termination occurs within 2 years after a change of control) No mitigation or offset with these benefits. |
||
Involuntary Termination for Cause or Voluntary Termination not for Good Reason: |
Payment of all accrued and earned salary,
bonuses, expenses, etc. |
Same |
Definitions: |
Cause means (i) the willful failure by
Executive to attempt to substantially perform her duties with the Company (other than any such failure resulting from her incapacity due to physical or mental impairment), unless any such failure is corrected within thirty (30) days following written notice by the Board that specifically identifies the manner in which the Board believes Executive has substantially not attempted to materially perform her duties or (ii) the willful gross misconduct by Executive with regard to the Company that is materially injurious to the Company. No act, or failure to act, by Executive shall be willful unless committed without good faith and without a reasonable belief that the act or omission was in the best interest of the Company. No event shall be deemed the basis for Cause unless Executive is |
Same. CSF to waive clause (i) of
Good Reason definition in connection with the consummation of Project Abelard. |
- 4 -
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
terminated therefor within sixty (60) days after such event is known to the Chairman of the Company, or, if Executive is Chairman, known to the Chairman of any committee of the Board. Executive shall not be deemed to have been terminated for Cause without (i) advance written notice provided to Executive not less than fourteen (14) days prior to the date of termination setting forth the Companys intention to consider terminating Executive and including a statement of the proposed date of termination and the specific detailed basis for such consideration of termination for Cause, (ii) an opportunity of Executive, together with her counsel, to be heard before the Board at least ten (10) days after the giving of such notice and prior to the proposed date of termination, (iii) a duly adopted resolution of the Board stating that in accordance with the provisions of the next to the last sentence of this paragraph, the actions of Executive constituted Cause and the basis thereof, and (iv) a written determination provided by the Board setting forth the acts and omissions that form the basis of such termination of employment. Any determination by the Board hereunder shall be made by the affirmative vote of at least a two-thirds (2/3) majority of all of the members of the Board (other than Executive). Any purported termination of employment of Executive by the Company which does not meet each and every substantive and procedural requirement of this paragraph shall be treated for all purposes under this Agreement as a |
- 5 -
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
termination of employment without Cause. Good Reason means, without the express written consent of Executive, the occurrence of any of the following events: (i) any reduction or diminution (except temporarily during any period of disability) in Executives titles or positions, any material diminution in Executives authority, duties or responsibilities with the Company (it being acknowledged that, in the event any entity becomes the owner (directly or indirectly) of more than 35% of the Common Stock, it shall be Good Reason if Executive is not the Chief Executive Officer of such entity); (ii) a breach by the Company of any material provision of the Agreement, including, but not limited to, a breach of the Companys obligation with respect to Executives position and duties (as set forth in Section 1(a) of the Agreement), any reduction (other than a reduction (not to exceed ten percent (10%)) that applies, in equal percentages, to all U.S. officers (within the meaning of Section 16 of the Securities and Exchange Act of 1934, as amended) of the Company) in Executives Base Salary or any material failure to timely pay any part of Executives compensation (including, without limitation, Base Salary, annualized Target Pay and bonus) or to materially provide in the aggregate the level of benefits contemplated herein; (iii) the failure of the Company to obtain and deliver to Executive a satisfactory written agreement from any successor to the Company to assume and agree to perform the Agreement; or |
- 6 -
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
(iv) the failure to appoint or elect Executive to the Board within thirty (30) days of the Employment Commencement Date or at any time thereafter or the removal of Executive therefrom. |
||
Golden Parachute Issues: | Full gross-up for excise tax | Same |
Non-Compete; Non-Solicit: |
24 months post-termination Executive cannot provide services for *** organizations designated by the Board *** |
24 months post-termination, which
as to non-compete means that Executive cannot provide services for 3 organizations to be named by the Board No non-compete following an Involuntary Termination without Cause or Voluntary Termination for Good Reason which occurs after a change of control |
Attorney and Consultant Fees: |
Company responsible for reasonable legal fees associated with agreement |
Same |
*** Confidential information omitted.
- 7 -
MDC EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT
Summary of Key Terms
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
Title: | Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Officer | President |
Board of Directors: | Serves as Chairman of the Board. | To be elected to the Board of Directors |
Duties: | All the duties and responsibilities commensurate with Executives role. All other employees of the Company report to the Executive or his designee. | Manage individual BUs Ensure execution of stated strategies Ensure cross-BU sharing IP Sales force Other resources |
Term of Employment: | 3 year term (October 1, 2000 to September 30, 2003); automatic 1 year-renewal. | 24 month term at will thereafter Agreement continues in effect throughout employment with the Company |
Base Salary: | Not less than $1,600,000 base salary per year. If Board increases salary during term, may not be reduced. | $1,600,000 per year |
Benefits: | Eligible for same benefits and perquisites as other Company executives. | Same as CSF
(including, among other things, personal security, use of Company plane, car and financial planning as currently provided to MDC) and relocation benefits (including mortgage assistance, |
-8-
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
relocation tax
reimbursement, and other relocation costs comparable to those provided to CSF) |
||
Bonus: |
Current target annual bonus is 2 x base salary $850,000 special bonus upon execution of the Agreement |
Target annual incentive of $3,200,000 (2 x base salary) |
Equity Compensation: |
Special 1999 Stock Option Grant for 1 million shares 1999 Restricted Stock Grant for 200,000 shares 2000 Restricted Stock Grant for 970,000 shares Note: Agreement provides for target long- term incentives of 7-10x base salary |
4 million share option grant2 Eligible for ongoing awards at levels commensurate with position |
-9-
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
Loans: |
$5 million loan to purchase shares under
prior employment agreement to be forgiven over 3
years, commencing November 1, 2001
$2.5 million full recourse loan to assist
with taxes associated under the Agreement due
in 2005 (or within 120 days after
non-Qualifying Termination of employment, if
earlier)
|
None |
Death or Disability: |
Disability Executive is inability to
perform the essential functions of Executives
position as CEO or to perform as Chairman of
the Board, as a result of illness or injury
for six consecutive months. Executive gets (i) lump sum equal to 1.5 x base salary and target bonus, (ii) prorated annual incentive, (iii) forgiveness of $5 million loan and (iv) no acceleration of $2.5 million tax assistance loan. |
Disability Executive is unable to
perform his material duties hereunder for six consecutive months because of physical or mental incapacity Executive gets (i) 100% vesting in all equity compensation awards, (ii) payment of all accrued salary, bonuses, expenses, etc., (iii) pro-rata bonus under Companys variable pay plan and (iv) lump sum equal to 1.5 x base salary and target bonus. |
Change of Control Vesting Acceleration |
100% vesting of restricted stock on change of
control per 1989 Equity Incentive Plan and
100% vesting of options on change of control
per 1998 Stock Option Plan. |
On the date of a change of control (a)
100% vesting of any restricted stock or restricted stock unit, and (b) 50% vesting of each tranche of each option and of each tranche of each other equity award. |
Qualifying Termination: |
Qualifying Termination means any of the
following: (1) Involuntary termination without Cause (2) Resignation within 90 day of a Good Reason (3) Involuntary termination within 180 days of a |
Qualifying Termination means
involuntary termination by the Company
without Cause or resignation by Executive for Good Reason within 180 days of Good Reason event. |
-10-
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
Change of Control |
|
|
Payments and Benefits upon a Qualifying Termination: |
Separation payment equal to 3 x base salary and target bonus Pro-rated annual incentive Continued vesting in any unvested stock options for 2 years 3 years (or expiration of option, if earlier) to exercise any options that are or become vested Vest in a pro-rated portion of 200,000 shares under 1999 Restricted Stock Grant Vest in 470,000 shares of 2000 Restricted Stock Grant Forgiveness of outstanding balance of $5 million loan to purchase shares No acceleration of $2.5 million tax assistance loan Lump sum payment of $100,000 6 months paid COBRA coverage |
Upon termination by Executive for Good
Reason (within 180 days of Good Reason event) or by the Company without Cause, Executive gets: Accrued salary, bonuses, expenses, etc. Pro-rata bonus under Companys variable pay plan 2 x base salary and target bonus (paid out over 24 months) subject to non- compete clawback. Severance paid out in lump sum if change of control after termination. If termination occurs in contemplation of, or within 2 years after change of control, Executive gets 3 x base salary and highest bonus earned with respect to 2 fiscal years prior to termination, whether or not previously paid 2 years of continued participation in Companys welfare plans (3 years if termination occurs within 2 years after change of control) 3 years of service and compensation credit under Companys defined benefit type retirement plans if termination occurs within 2 years after change of control 100% vesting in restricted stock and restricted units to be granted 50% vesting of each tranche of each |
-11-
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
stock option and of each tranche of each other equity award (100% vesting if termination occurs within 2 years after change of control) 3 years post-termination to exercise all options 1 year of customary outplacement services No acceleration of $2.5 million tax assistance loan No mitigation or offset with these benefits. |
||
Severance Offset: | Through one year after close,
severance payable under this Agreement
offset by severance under Church
employment agreement. No offset under
this Agreement for retention payments. |
|
Involuntary Termination for Cause or Resignation without Good Reason: |
No severance is payable. | Payment of all accrued and earned salary, bonuses, expenses, etc. |
Definitions: |
Cause means a good faith determination by the
Board of Directors, after consultation with
outside legal counsel, that you have committed an act or omission that is materially contrary to the best interests of Church or that Executive has materially breached any of the terms and conditions of the Agreement. Executive will not be deemed to have been involuntarily terminated for Cause unless he is presented with a resolution of the Board of Directors, approved by at least 3/4 of the entire membership of the Board after |
Cause means (i) the willful failure by
Executive to attempt to substantially
perform his duties with the Company (other than any such failure resulting from his incapacity due to physical or mental impairment), unless any such failure is corrected within thirty (30) days following written notice by the Board that specifically identifies the manner in which the Board believes Executive has substantially not attempted to materially |
-12-
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
providing him with reasonable notice
and opportunity to be heard, with counsel,
before the Board, finding that he has engaged in
conduct which would constitute Cause under the
Agreement. Good Reason shall mean (a) involuntary removal from the position of Chief Executive Officer, (b) involuntary removal from, or failure to be elected, Chairman of the Board, (c) assignment, by the Board, of duties inconsistent with the position of Chief Executive Officer, (d) receipt of a notice of non-renewal of the Agreement, or (e) approval by the Board of a material reduction in target compensation (unless applicable to other executives). |
perform his duties or (ii)
the willful gross misconduct by Executive with regard to the Company that is materially injurious to the Company. No act, or failure to act, by Executive shall be willful unless committed without good faith and without a reasonable belief that the act or omission was in the best interest of the Company. No event shall be deemed the basis for Cause unless Executive is terminated therefor within sixty (60) days after such event is known to the Chairman of the Company, or, Executive is Chairman, known to the Chairman of any committee of the Board. Executive shall not be deemed to have been terminated for Cause without (i) advance written notice provided to Executive not less than fourteen (14) days prior to the date of termination setting forth the Companys intention to consider terminating Executive and including a statement of the proposed date of termination and the specific detailed basis for such consideration of termination for Cause, (ii) an opportunity of Executive, together with his counsel, to be heard before the Board at least ten (10) days after the giving of such notice and prior to the proposed date of termination, (iii) a duly adopted resolution of the Board stating that in accordance with the provisions of the |
-13-
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
next to the last
sentence of this paragraph, the actions of Executive constituted Cause and the basis thereof, and (iv) a written determination provided by the Board setting forth the acts and omissions that form the basis of such termination of employment. Any determination by the Board hereunder shall be made by the affirmative vote of a least a two-thirds (2/3) majority of all of the members of the Board (other than Executive). Any purported termination of employment of Executive by the Company which does not meet each and every substantive and procedural requirement of this paragraph shall be treated for all purposes under this Agreement as a termination of employment without Cause. Good Reason means, without the express written consent of Executive, the occurrence of any of the following events: (i) any reduction or diminution (except temporarily during any period of disability) in Executives titles or positions, or any material diminution in Executives authority, duties or responsibilities with the Company (it being acknowledged that, in the event any entity becomes the owner (directly or indirectly) of more than 35% of the Common Stock, it shall be Good Reason if Executive is not the President of such entity); (ii) a breach by the Company |
-14-
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
of any material provision of the Agreement, including, but not limited to, a breach of the Companys obligation under position/duties section of the Agreement, any reduction (other than a reduction (not to exceed ten percent (10%)) that applies, in equal percentages, to all U.S. officers (within the meaning of Section 16 of the Securities and Exchange Act of 1934, as amended) of the Company) in Executives Base Salary or any material failure to timely pay any part of Executives compensation (including, without limitation, Base Salary, annualized Target Pay and bonus) or to materially provide in the aggregate the level of benefits contemplated in the Agreement; (iii) the failure of the Company to obtain and deliver to Executive a satisfactory written agreement from any successor to the Company to assume and agree to perform the Agreement; or (iv) the failure to appoint or elect Executive to the Board within thirty (30) days of the Employment Commencement Date or at any time thereafter or the removal of Executive therefrom. |
||
Golden Parachute Issues: | Full gross-up for excise tax | Full gross-up for excise tax |
Non-Compete; Non-Solicit: | 24 month post-termination non-compete, non-solicit, non-disparagement | 24 months post-termination, which as
to non-compete means that Executive cannot provide services for 3 organizations to be |
-15-
Term | Existing Agreement | Proposed Agreement |
named by the
Board No non-compete following an Involuntary Termination without Cause or Voluntary Termination for Good Reason which occurs after a change of control |
||
Attorney and Consultant Fees: |
Lump sum payment of $100,000 upon a Qualifying
Termination intended to cover, among other things, accounting or legal fees necessitated by Executives termination of employment. |
Company
responsible for reasonable legal fees associated with agreement |
-16-
COMPENSATION COMMITTEE AGENDA
September 3, 2001
7:00 am Conference Call
1. | Review Employment Contracts for Carly & Michael | |||
2. | Formula for Performance-Based Options | |||
3. | Adoption of 2001 Executive Transition Program | |||
4. | Retention Packages for Selected Tier I Employees | |||
5. | Employment Contracts for Ten Key Leaders | |||
Proposed Employment Agreements
Term | CSF | MDC |
Title | Chairman and CEO | President |
Duties |
Lead corporation Decide new top level structure Establish integration effort Oversee integration effort Lead BU performance management Manage board constituents External spokesperson on direction |
Manage individual BUs Ensure execution of stated strategies Ensure cross-BU sharing - IP; Sales force; Other resources |
Base Salary | $1,600,000 | $1,600,000 |
Term of Agreement | 2 years, at-will thereafter | 2 years, at-will thereafter |
Target Annual Incentive | $4,800,000 (3 x base salary) | $3,200,000 (2 x base salary) |
Equity Compensation |
6 million option shares:
35% time-based vesting over 3 years 65% performance based with price targets for 1/3rd of shares subject to option equal to 120%, 125% and 140% of FMV respectively and vesting based on achievement of such price targets Total estimated current value - [$57 million] |
4 million
option shares: 35% time-based vesting over 3 years 65% performance based with price targets for 1/3rd of shares subject to option equal to 120%, 125% and 140% of FMV respectively and vesting based on achievement of such price targets Total estimated current value [$38 million] |
Severance |
2 x base salary and target bonus
(3 x base salary and high bonus if within 2 years after a change of control) 2 years continued participation in welfare plans (3 years if related to change of control) and 3 years of service and compensation credit under retirement plans if related to change of control 100% acceleration of restricted stock grant and restricted stock award 50% acceleration of unvested shares subject to any options (100% if related to change of control) |
2 x base salary and target bonus (3
x base salary and high bonus if within 2 years after a change of control) 2 years continued participation in welfare plans (3 years if related to change of control) and 3 years of service and compensation credit under retirement plans if related to change of control 100% acceleration of any restricted stock grant and restricted stock award 50% acceleration of unvested shares subject to any options (100% if related to change of control) |
Severance/Retention Offset | Through one year after close, severance payable under this Agreement offset by severance/retention under Church agreement. Through the second year after close, severance payable under this Agreement offset by retention provided under Church agreement. |
|
Golden Parachute Provision | Full excise tax gross-up | Full excise tax gross-up |
Non-Compete |
2 year post termination limited
to 3 organizations to be named by the Board |
2 year post termination limited to
3 organizations to be named by the Board |
Existing Employment Agreements
Term | CSF | MDC |
Title | Chairman, President and CEO | Chairman and CEO |
Base Salary | $1 million | Not less than $1.6 million |
Target Bonus |
$3 million signing bonus $3 to $9 million annual bonus |
$850,000 signing
bonus 2 x base salary |
Equity Compensation |
3.8 million option shares 1.4 million restricted stock shares Eligibility for ongoing awards Total current value $23 million |
1 million option shares 200,000 restricted stock grant (1999) 970,000 restricted stock grant (2000) Total current value Agreement provides for long-term incentive of 7- 10x base |
Loans | N/A | $5 million
loan to purchase shares $2.5 million tax assistance loan |
Constructive Termination Severance |
2 x base salary and target bonus
(3 x base salary and high bonus if within 2 years after a change of control) 2 years continued participation in welfare plans (3 years if related to change of control) and 3 years of service and compensation credit under retirement plans if related to change of control 100% acceleration of restricted stock grant and restricted stock award 50% acceleration of unvested shares subject to any options (100% if related to change of control) |
3 x base salary and target bonus Pro-rata annual incentive Continued option vesting for 2 years 3 year post-termination period to exercise options Vest in pro-rata portion of 200,000 restricted stock grant Vest in 470,000 shares of 970,000 restricted stock grant Forgiveness of $5 million loan; no acceleration of $2.5 million loan $100,000 lump sum payment 6 months paid COBRA |
Change in Control
Benefits (single trigger) |
100% acceleration of restricted
stock grant and restricted stock award and 50% acceleration of unvested options |
N/A |
Golden Parachute Provision | Full excise tax gross-up | Full excise tax gross-up |
Non-Compete/Non-Solicitation | 2 year post-termination *** | 2 year post-termination |
*** Confidential information omitted.
1
Date: | Ann O. Baskins |
2
MINUTES OF THE COMPENSATION COMMITTEE
OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
OF HEWLETT-PACKARD COMPANY
September 20, 2001
|
||
[Certain
information has been omitted because it does not relate to the employment agreements contemplated for Carleton Fiorina and Michael Capellas.] |
||
|
||
III. |
[Certain information has been omitted because it does not relate to the employment agreements contemplated for Carleton Fiorina and Michael Capellas]
VI. | Proposed Employment Agreements | |
Phil Condit rejoined the meeting. | ||
James Otieno reviewed prior Committee decisions and discussions regarding
guiding principles for employment agreements for the top twelve managers of the new HP. Otieno described design objectives for the agreements, including being competitive and performance driven and being able to withstand shareholder, employee and investment community scrutiny. Otieno then reported that he and his counterpart at Compaq had agreed on a conceptual framework, subject to discussion and approval by the Committee. |
||
Larry Sonsini then described the Companys commitment, pursuant to a side
letter signed by outside counsel, to negotiate in good faith employment agreements for certain named individuals. |
2
Carly Fiorina rejoined the meeting at this time. | ||
The Committee then discussed design issues associated with the stock
option component of the employment agreements under consideration. Committee members expressed their continuing preference for linking option vesting to performance. Phil Condit rejoined the meeting, and the Committee reviewed possible performance metrics for the stock options. It was generally agreed that vesting should be tied to stock price growth in defined time periods and that value drivers associated with the deal would be an appropriate secondary metric. Discussion ensued regarding what share price growth should trigger vesting. To provide context for the discussion, Sam Ginn recapped discussions over the last several weeks regarding the structure of the options, which are expected to be granted at the close of the merger. |
||
Following extensive discussion, the Committee developed a framework* for
the options, a copy of which is attached to these minutes, which provides for a.) 25 percent of the option shares to time- vest over three years; b.) three-25 percent option tranches to vest upon the attainment of defined stock price targets in specified time frames; c.) with respect to each of the stock price performance-based blocks, Afail-safe@ vesting of 50 percent of the block if the relevant stock price target is not met but certain defined value creation metrics are met; and d.) the opportunity to Arecapture@ vesting for a block if initial stock price targets are missed but value capture metrics are met and the stock price meets or exceeds 200 percent of the option exercise price within four years. Larry Sonsini was instructed to propose the structure to the chairman of Compaqs compensation committee and report back on his reaction. |
||
Additional features of the proposed compensation packages were discussed,
with attention paid to the constituent components of the package. It was noted that the agreements, including the cash compensation levels and the option grants, contemplate a two-year term. The Committee also clarified its intent with respect to how retirement and other termination events would affect options granted pursuant to the agreements. It was agreed that options held for at least two years after grant and before retirement would continue to Aride@, i.e. recipients would be treated as though they were still employed with respect to vesting and exercisability. However, a recipient who retires less than two years following grant would be eligible only for partial vesting. |
||
Finally, the Committee asked that the staff reopen with Compaq issues
associated with the lack of offset between severance and retention payments for its employees in the Tier two and below categories. |
||
* Subsequent to the adjournment of the meeting, members of the Committee
determined that the Committee had not agreed on the exercise price for the options, specifically whether the performance-based blocks would be priced at FMV or premium prices. |
||
3
Fiorina then left the meeting. | ||
VII. | Fiorina Employment Contract | |
James Otieno outlined the terms of the existing employment agreement with
Carly Fiorina. The agreement was reviewed in the context of the revised duties contemplated upon the close of the merger and in light of the Capellas contract. The Committee reviewed and discussed the base and bonus cash components, the possible bonus amounts at the aspirational level and the total package value. Following some discussion, the Committee approved new employment agreement terms, effective on the merger, including a base salary increase from $1M to $1.6M, an increase in the annual bonus at target to $4.8M and a new option grant of 6M shares on the terms reflected in the preceding discussion on options associated with employment packages*. The Committee also approved an $8M retention package consistent with the retention terms approved at the September 3, 2001 meeting of the Committee. |
||
[Certain information has been omitted because it does not relate to the employment agreements contemplated for Carleton Fiorina and Michael Capellas]
4
* As noted previously, it was subsequently determined that the Committee
had not reached agreement on the pricing terms of the option component of the package. Accordingly, all components of the package, which are interrelated, will be reconsidered at a future meeting. |
5